Recusol™, central air heater

By: Innovy | 1-Apr-2009 | 0:00 am | Mail idea | Print idea | RSS

The Recusol™ is a sustainable and cheap central air heating system, which consumes only energy for a small fan, which in most cases already is available in a building. The Recusol™ is a recuperator and a solar collector that recovers both energy from waste ventilation air and from (sun) light.
The Recusol™ consists of a transparent large area flat heat exchanger made of special polycarbonate multi wall sheets or channel plate, which has on the back side a (sun) light absorber. Due to the large surface the flow losses are small, so a small fan power is required and minor or no noise production is generated. In a feasibility study sponsored by the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, program EOS, executed by SenterNovem the technical and economic feasibility was established.

Figure 1: Example Recusol™; central air heater with energy from heat recovery and (sun) light heat

The main conclusions are:

The Recusol™ is cost effective and around 2 times cheaper in use than a conventional central heating system. With the expected increase of energy costs in the future, the reduction will be larger.

Because air is used as transport medium the cheap Recusol™ can directly use the infrastructure of an existing ventilation system, which makes it even cheaper.

Due to the high efficiency a relative small collector area is required and also a small cheap monthly storage, which is provided from the soil directly underneath the building. With this storage it is also possible to keep the house cool during hot periods in the summer, with the same equipment applied for the heating.

The Recusol™ consumes only the energy for the small fan and the water pump for the heat storage. In the winter, during long cold periods without sun, a small extra heat source might be required.
The savings on primary energy and CO2 are > 90%, while even up to a 100% if the electricity comes from a sustainable source.

The Recusol™ is a cheap way to satisfy the Kyoto protocol

The Recusol™ is also cheaper then a heat pump, because the investment costs of a heat pump are higher and the heat pump consumes more electric energy as well.


It was found that due to the relative large surface a lot of (sun) light energy can be caught, while the heat recovery efficiency is high (>95%.) The losses of the (sun) light absorber are limited to the low losses already present in the heat exchanger. At cold ambient weather it is possible to transfer (sun) light in heat with high efficiency. For example at a temperature of 0 ºC the efficiency is calculated to be between 60% and 70%.

To avoid too much short circuit in the heat flow the heat exchanger should be thicker than 6 cm, while the walls between the hot and cold media should be as thin as possible. Also the air speed should be high enough to avoid heat back flow in the transported air (expressed in the Peclet number, which should be >> 1). To avoid radiation losses the front of the Recusol™ can be provided with a spectral selective layer. With these conditions the heat resistance of a 6 cm thick Recusol™ is the same as a 25 cm thick glass wool blanket. With the 2 cm transport channels on both sides the total thickness of the Recusol™ is 10 cm.

Figure 2: Recusol™ made of 4 walled polycarbonate or PMMA sheet

Figure 3: Cross section A-A cross section B-B of figure 2

Figure 4: Temperature distribution over Recusol™ at waste in 20 ºC and fresh in 0 ºC

A larger comfort is performed if the actual excess of sun heat is stored in a heat storage by an extra heat exchanger before the air enters the ventilation system of the building. This stored heat can be used at a later time if there is heat shortage. In the feasibility study it was found that monthly storage is sufficient. For this short period the excess heat can be stored directly under the building by small U-tubes pulsed around the building. Due to the short period the same storage system can be used in the summer for the storage of cold from the night air, which can cool the building during hot periods.

To avoid dirt the inlet and outlet of the Recusol™ should be filtered. Possible still present micro-organisms will be killed by regularly available high sun intensity, while with the transparent Recusol™ dirt is easy visible during inspection.

The transport channels in the Recusol™ are designed to remove condense; while possible ice depletion will be removed by temporarily turning around the flows, such that the ice will melt by the warm waste air.

Figure 5: Operation of Recusol™ and storage during winter and summer

Proof of principle

Before starting further development a simple proof of principle was executed by Innovy in Alkmaar. A test sample is produced from adapted polycarbonate multi wall sheets in which small air distribution holes are stabbed with a pin. After that new channels are assembled by gluing the adapted channels with thin polycarbonate plates used for the heat exchanger. The small sample is placed in a test rig representing a down scaled building with a scale of 1:67.
Because standard available multi wall sheet is applied with 8 mm wide channels it was not possible to fabricate the optimal design with 5 mm wide channels. If 5 mm wide, there are 200 channels per m with a K-value of 600 W/K per m² Recusol™, which is very large for an air to air heat exchanger. If 8 mm wide, the K value is 234 W/K per m² Recusol™, which is still rather high for an air to air heat exchanger but 60% less than for a 5 mm channel.

Figure 6: Test sample and test rig on a 1:67 scale of a standard family house.

Because the heat exchange channels were glued instead of extruded, one channel leaked and effectively 2 of the 19 channels were blocked by rest glue material, so 86% of the sample did operate well. Also due to the glue the sample was less transparent: around 40% of the light went through the sample and was absorbed by the black absorber, around 20% was reflected and around 40% was absorbed by the heat exchange channels and transport channels.

The test rig represents a well insulated (12 cm thick glass wool and HR++ windows) standard family house (a house between two other houses) with the characteristics given in the table below:

Subject family house test rig comments
Ventilation rate 300 m³/h 4.4 m³/h Scale 1: 67
Ventilation heat loss rate 110 W/K 0.1 W/K test rig 90% recovery
Insulation heat loss rate 92 W/K 1.37 W/K Scale 1: 67
Passive heat 1100 W 16 W Internal heat sources
Planned Recusol™ area 10 m² 0.15 m² Scale 1: 67

Table 1: Specifications of the test rig and the standard family house it represents

The internal heat sources are electric equipment, people, cooking, passive (sun) light through windows, etc.

A test performed around the shortest day of the year is shown in figure 7.

Figure 7: test at Alkmaar from 17 December up to 19 December 2008

From the test can be concluded that the recovery efficiency of the waste air heat is between 80 and 95%, which is rather high for a far from perfect test sample. The solar absorption efficiency is 50%, from which 40%-point is recovered by the heat absorber and 10%-point by the heat exchanger, absorbed by the not perfect transparent channels, while approximately 22%-point is reflected by the not perfect transparent channels. The remaining 28%-point is lost in the waste air exhaust of the Recusol™.
It is thought that if the transport channels were designed in counter flow more absorbed heat of the remaining 28%-point will be recovered. In that case the solar absorption efficiency will be 60%.
If the test sample is extruded instead of clued the channels would be more transparent and also less light will be reflected. In that case with the application of counter flow in the transport channels it is expected that the solar efficiency will be 70%.
Never the less the test with the glued sample shows that the Recusol™ is moderate sensitive on dirt, because part of the (sun) light heat absorbed by the dirt will be recovered by the heat exchanger. Also because the absorber is very well insulated (comparable with 24 cm thick glass wool) the efficiency is hardly sensitive to the outside temperature.

In figure 8 a test is shown over a longer period, which was rather cold for Alkmaar.

Figure 8: test at Alkmaar during a cold period from end 2008 up to begin 2009

The “house in” temperature was maximal 65 ºC and would be higher if the leaveless tree from the neighbours positioned in the south was not present. If the heat was stored the temperature in the test rig (house) would be between 22 ºC and 24 ºC and sufficient for this cold period.
This confirms that a short storage period is sufficient as well.

Cost estimation compared with conventional central heating

Based on series production the estimated costs for a standard family house are:

Component Recusol™ Conventional
Heater 2000 € (10 m²) 1500 €
Tubing and radiators 1000 € 1000 €
Airco 0 1000 €
Storage 3000 € 0
Assembly 1500 € 500 €
Total investment cost 7500 € 4000 €
Life 25 year Active components 15 year
Life Storage 40 year Passive components 30 year
Investment cost per year 460 €/y 350 €/y
Maintenance 70 €/y 100 €/y
Energy cost 120 €/y 790 €/y
Total cost per year 650 €/y 1240 €/y
Percentage of conventional 51 % 100 %

Table 2: cost of Recusol™ compared with conventional central heating and airco

For a standard family house 49% on costs are saved.
Also 2500 kg CO2 is saved per year.
If the house is poor insulated (K=value 184 W/K instead of 92 W/K) the total costs are resp. for the Recusol™ 1006 €/y and for the conventional central heating 1603 €/y, which is 38% cheaper and significant too. However compared with the well insulated house 500 kg more CO2 per year is used, so for the environment it is recommended to apply a well insulated house.

Temperature scenario´s

Based on measured temperatures and sun input at De Bilt the Netherlands the temperature in a standard family house is calculated for the years 2001 up to the beginning of 2007.
Figure 9 shows the temperatures and possible extra heating by an extra mood heater during the heating season. Figure 10 shows the temperatures during the cooling season.

Figure 9: Temperatures of a standard family house with a 20 m² Recusol™ during heating season at De Bilt the Netherlands

The heating by the 20 m² Recusol™ and the storage (30 m³ soil) is sufficient to heat the house, only in 2003 and 2006 a small 1000 W mood heater would have been needed with a mean consumption of 47 m³/y NG. If a 10 m² Recusol™ is applied in all years an extra heater of 2000 W would have been needed, with a mean consumption of 140 m³/y of NG.

Figure 10: Temperatures of a standard family house with a 10 m² Recusol™ during cooling season at De Bilt the Netherlands

With the storage of cold from the night air, only for a short period in 2003 and 2006 the temperature of the house exceeded 25 ºC.

Critical points

Critical points are:
• Dirt scale on the Recusol™ surfaces
• Condense
• Ice

Most of the dirt will be removed by the filters placed before the waste and the fresh air input. Because dirt also absorbs heat, from which a large part is recovered, the Recusol™ is not that sensitive to dirt. Possible micro organisms will regularly be killed by the heat of the sun, while due to the transparent Recusol™ dirt can easily be detected and possibly break down by UV light or special gasses.

In the heat exchange channels special drains will be applied which removes the condense to the bottom, where it should be tapped regularly.

If ice is present it can be removed by turning around the flows inside the Recusol™, such that the cold side will be heated by the hot input waste air, which will melt the ice.

Figure 11: Without heat absorber; high efficient day light window Recupane™ (U-value around 0.2 W/Km²) and ventilation per room with heat recovery and extra passive heat from (sun) light

Figure 12: Example Recusol™ in combination with PV both with its own preferred azimuth angle (resp. January mean and year mean)

© 2009 Innovy


By: Bas | 15-Apr-2009 | 2:14 pm

I am totally lost on this "Recusol" thing. Even as a experienced mechanical engineer, the sketches are unclear to me (where is the fan?), and the words seem fuzzy. Is it possible to explain what the crux of this thing is, for "dummies"? Can I download a copy of the feasibility study?

By: Innovy | 17-Apr-2009 | 10:58 pm

For a better insight I added figure 2. The fan is in the fresh air inlet on the roof of the building (see figure 5). If inside the building, under-pressure or ambient-pressure is required, other possibilities are applicable (one fan in the waste air circuit or two fans; one in the waste and one in the fresh air circuit).
A summary of the feasibility study (in Dutch) is available on request. The crux of the Recusol is that a recuperator and a solar collector are integrated in one very efficient and cost effective product.

By: Gimena | 23-Jun-2013 | 10:18 am

JaneIs this is a package unit with gas heat? The heat execanghr is the part that heats the air. The blower forces the room air around the execanghr which heats it. The gas burner heats the inside of the execanghr.If it gets a crack or rusts out you will have combustion byproducts entering the building.

By: Darence | 24-Jun-2013 | 1:56 am

Thanks for inrtoduicng a little rationality into this debate.

By: Adrian | 24-Jun-2013 | 7:19 am

solar water heating smtseys are reasonably inexpensive, as discussed in a posting on affordable solar power, we noted that with available tax credits, you can get your materials cost almost to zero (with the

By: Cecy | 24-Jun-2013 | 8:17 am

Earth Science Questions!!?? Plz I Need Help??????????????????1. By studying vrinatioas in color of the ocean, scientists can determine the presence of A. sea mammals.B. phytoplankton.C. oxygen.D. trace elements. 2. Oceans are often referred to as a carbon sink. How many times more carbon is contained in the ocean than in the atmosphere? A. 20 times moreB. 40 times moreC. 60 times moreD. 80 times more 3. The two principal gases dissolved in ocean water are A. carbon dioxide and oxygen.B. oxygen and hydrogen.C. hydrogen and nitrogen.D. nitrogen and oxygen. 4. Which of the following results in an increase in ocean salinity? A. The rate of evaporation is higher than the rate of precipitationB. The rate of precipitation is higher than the rate of evaporationC. The rate of condensation is higher than the rate of precipitationD. The rate of precipitation is higher than the rate of condensation 5. Global oceans have an average salinity of A. 34.7%.B. 27.3%.C. 40.1%.D. 10.8%. 6. The range of ocean temperatures is affected by A. storms and proximity to land masses.B. the moon and proximity to land masses.C. solar energy and water movement.D. the percent of salt and other trace minerals. 7. A thermocline is a layer in a body of water in which water A. acts as an insulator against solar energy.B. temperature drops with increased depth faster than any other layers.C. temperature increases with increased depth faster than any other layers.D. temperature is ideal for polar marine life to flourish. 8. Two factors that affect the density of ocean water is A. salinity and trace minerals.B. water temperature and phytoplankton.C. nitrogen and carbon dioxide levels.D. salinity and water temperature. 9. The ocean can be divided into what two basic environments? A. benthic zone and pelagic zoneB. plant and marine lifeC. polar and nonpolar zonesD. abyssal zone and intertidal zone 10. The benthic zone contains marine life that A. are the size of plankton.B. are surface feeders.C. are bottom-dwelling.D. live in ocean trenches. 11. The ocean environment that receives the most solar energy and is home to the most diverse ocean life forms is the A. continental shelf.B. benthic zone.C. pelagic zone.D. upwelling. 12. Which zone within the pelagic environment is ideal for marine life? A. oceanic zoneB. neritic zoneC. bathyal zoneD. hadal zone 13. Which zone lies below the 6,000 meter depth? A. abyssal zoneB. oceanic zoneC. bathyal zoneD. hadal zone 14. Which zone within the benthic environment is ideal for most marine organism growth? A. sublittoral zoneB. intertidal zoneC. abyssal zoneD. oceanic zone 15. What causes the movement of deep, cold, nutrient-rich water to the surface in an upwelling? A. deep-ocean earthquakesB. steady winds blowing parallel to the coast lineC. glaciers moving into the oceanD. underwater volcanic activity 16. Plankton are the foundation of life in the ocean because they A. are at the top of the ocean food chain.B. establish a proper environment for all sea life.C. balance the chemical composition of the ocean habitat.D. form the base of the ocean food chain. 17. The oceans provide means of transportation and resources such as food, minerals, and A. hydro electricity.B. thermal heat.C. fresh water.D. sea curren

By: Moussa | 25-Jun-2013 | 10:21 am

It is hot in here?A furnace on and off. It doesn't work like a vomlue control, more like a mute button it's either running full bore or not running at all. Regardless of whether you set the thermostat for 68 or 85, it will take the same amount of time to heat the house from 60 to 68 degrees.For the record, this also is true for air conditioning the A/C is either on or off. Setting it to 60 won't cool it down from 85 any faster than setting it for 75. By using your thermostat correctly and intelligently, you will still be able to bring your home to a comfortable temperature without dramatically inflating your energy bills.So yes, just set the thermostat for the temperature you want it to be in the house.Other tipsOf course, although the furnace may only run at one speed and heat level, there are some things you can do to help your heating/cooling situation.Close the doors and windows. I know this is kind of a duh? statement, but double check before you fire up the heat or A/C.Close the blinds. They can help keep heat in or out, depending on the season. Also, consider energy-saving curtains with special insulation liners. They can help control room temperature for a relatively inexpensive investment.Check your insulation. Still got the original insulation from when your house was built 40 years ago? Yeah, you might want to have some new stuff added. Most older homes can greatly benefit from having an additional layer of blown-in insulation added.Check for leaks. When the wind blows, can you feel it come through your closed window? Might want to grab a tube of caulk and seal that up a bit.Upgrade your windows. Single pane windows keep the rain and dust out, but that's about it. They're almost useless from an insulation standpoint.GD Star Ratingloading...

By: Kiran | 25-Jun-2013 | 10:46 am

Exactly! The problem of the pelpoe here nowadays is 'sticking with "comfort zone"'! Actually, it is not only the problem of the children (including teenagers), but also of nearly everybody. Otherwise, WHY do the pelpoe spend (waste? :-P) so much time, money and effort for all sorts of certs, dips and qualifications? And WHY shall employers ONLY want (or only choose) applicants with 'RELEVANT qualifications'??? THAT is a MAJOR PROBLEM of this society!!!

By: Maria | 25-Jun-2013 | 10:48 am

That we have in our country Tunisia, a large bay to the tide and wihtin the Gulf Valleys great place pressure highly Alterat and I imagine it is possible to produce huge energy from electricity to Vhama Vainni invite you to visit the place and he can make a project electrically Dkhmamn energy Alndifa and sustainable and can benefit the whole world Salami and Hkuraanoan Ben Bachir Alajnf or Shosha, PO Box 3018 Sfax, Tunisia

By: Zara | 25-Jun-2013 | 11:41 am

There has been such a gap in my story online and part of the jounrey was do the healing that was needed and not record it. Hard to explain that after so many years of journal projects and having everyone who came through the Talk Zone be so personally involved with our healing. There is a point at which some healing has to be done alone. And I would guess that is when we are strong enough to go it alone. Which of course for me seems to have made these last years some of the hardest in many ways. I will say though the most rewarding because there was no one to answer to accept myself. As new students/friends/fellow advocates are coming through the Talk Zone I will do my best to get this started and active again. Truthfully though not hard to find the topics, it is truly choosing which one to start with again. So today we start with the first question asked and then work from there. Each day I'll pick the first question if I can and place my replies and answers with them. If there is no question that morning I'll pick something else and put the questions in the next morning. I am trying to limit the time I spend at this each day so not to over do it as before. Yep, there is such a thing as doing to much online. Who would have thought! lol Hugs and Healing for everyone! Lady J

By: Jose | 25-Jun-2013 | 2:00 pm

I really like your web site.. quite woferdnul colours & theme. Did you create this site yourself? Plz reply back again as I’m looking to create my own weblog and would like to know wheere u acquired this from. many thanks

Post comment:
Your name:
Your comment:
Validation image:
Enter the numbers shown in the validation image.
Posted by

GreenIdeaLive ©2017 All rights reserved | Contact | Site disclaimer | Illustrations by: | Webdevelopment | Xsdot is an Innovy initiative.   Innovy - Energy innovations